This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
In search of a smokeless ashtray to minimize the second-hand smoke and odors in your home or car? Here you’ll find our reviews of 8 smokeless ashtrays and our pick for the best smokeless ashtray of 2023. We’ll even offer up four effective long-term smokeless ashtray alternatives.
If you’re looking for our experts’ number one pick, it’s the Holmes Smoke Grabber.
Everyone knows that if you have to smoke, it’s better to smoke outside than inside your home. But not everyone always has that luxury.
Sometimes, it can be cold winter blizzards or torrential summer downpours preventing smokers from lighting up outside. Other times, it simply may not make sense to get up and walk out every single time you want to smoke – especially in larger buildings and apartments.
As a result, many smokers are turning to smokeless ashtrays to reduce the odors commonly associated with smoking indoors. In this article, we will cover everything you need to know about smokeless ashtrays and go down our list of the top 8 smokeless ashtrays for 2023.
Keep reading, though, because if you’re searching for complete second-hand smoke elimination, look at the smokeless ashtray alternatives we recommend closer to the end.
Best Smokeless Ashtray Picks for 2023
Confused by all of the different smokeless ashtrays on the market? Need help determining which smokeless ashtray to buy or which is suitable for your intended use? We’re here to help. The following is our list of the top 8 best smokeless ashtrays of 2023.
Holmes Smoke Grabber
Best Performance for Its Cost
The Holmes Smoke Grabber is comfortably sitting at the top of our best smokeless ashtray list. Perhaps the most well-known out of all smoke eater ashtrays, the Smoke Grabber provides the best performance for its cost of any of the smokeless ashtrays on our list.
The Holmes Smoke Grabber is easy to operate – open its lid and let the ashtray do the rest. By opening the cover, you’re turning on the internal fan, and that’s it; you’re ready to smoke. When you want to turn it off, shut the Smoke Grabber’s lid, and the fan will turn off.
Thanks to its straightforward square design, the Holmes Smoke Grabber is easy to clean in just a few minutes with a damp cloth, cotton swabs, or Q-tips. Plus, like with most quality smokeless ashtrays, the insertable carbon filters are affordable, easy to replace, and long-lasting.
Gratefulbuys Smokeless Ashtray
Made from Fireproof Melamine
Constructed out of fireproof melamine, the Gratefulbuys Smokeless Ashtray is number two on our list thanks to its good performance and great value. While not as powerful as the Holmes, the Gratefulbuys ashtray still offers a solid level of smoke removal for its price.
This ashtray has a covered chamber to rest your cigarettes and cigars. Stick them in through the hole while you aren’t actively smoking, turn on the power switch, and let the internal fan suck in the smoke.
The covered top helps maximize the level of smoke being consumed by the ashtray. Still, the one downside with the Gratefulbuys Smokeless Ashtray is that the holes on the top limit the use of larger diameter cigars like Churchill and Torpedo – they won’t properly fit in.
Kingstar Smokeless Ashtray
Covered-Top Design for Maximum Containment
Like the last pick, the Kingstar Smokeless Ashtray is another tremendous covered-top smoke solution. As before, this covered top design works wonders in preventing smoke from escaping the smoke eater but again limits the size of cigars that can be used with it. For cigarette smokers, however, this won’t be an issue.
Great for single bedrooms and small apartments, the Kingstar Smokeless Ashtray is powered by two C-size batteries and absorbs smoke and odor through its dual rectangular charcoal filters. Almost noiseless, the Kingstar is one of the quieter operating smokeless ashtrays to make our top list.
Rerii Automotive Smokeless Ashtray
Fits into Most Vehicle Cup Holders
Made from fireproof synthetic material, the Rerii Automotive Smokeless Ashtray is our list’s best smokeless car ashtray. It’s highly portable and easy to bring along with you, and it fits snugly into the cup holders in most vehicles. It also has an inner LED light for use at night.
The Rerii Automotive Smokeless Ashtray is a good choice if you’re looking for a smoke eater ashtray to leave in your car for driving. It’s easy to dump and clean whenever it’s full and keeps all smoke and ash odors inside the unit.
Smart TV Solutions Smokeless Ashtray
Cleanable and Reusable Filter
Another worthwhile open-top solution is the Smart TV Solutions Smokeless Ashtray. Battery-operated and easily transported anywhere, the Smart TV Solutions model is one of the best smokeless ashtrays to take with you on the go.
One significant benefit of the Smart TV Solutions Smokeless Ashtray compared to others on our list is that the included carbon filter can be removed and cleaned whenever it gets dirty and clogged up. This can significantly improve the filter’s lifespan and mean fewer and less frequent replacements.
However, please note that this smokeless ashtray from Smart TV Solutions is one of the noisier models we’ve reviewed, so it can work well in semi-outdoor spaces and garages but may not be well suited for quieter environments.
Zone Tech Car Smokeless Ashtray
Internal LED Lighting
Much like the Rerii Automotive Ashtray, a few spots higher on our list, the Zone Tech Car Smokeless Ashtray is a good choice for a portable smoke eater to keep your vehicle free of lingering and potentially-damaging smoke and odors.
Thanks to its internal lighting system, the Zone Tech ashtray is easy to see at night, meaning no accidentally ashing or dropping your cigarettes all over the floor. The inner diffuser constantly works to suck in and purify smoke whenever the unit’s lid is opened.
Although you can take and use the Zone Tech Car Smokeless Ashtray anywhere, it was specifically designed to fit into the cup holders in most vehicles and is best suited for that role.
Talon Capture Ionic Smokeless Ashtray
Utilizes a Negative Ion Engine
The only plug-in desktop smoke eater ashtray on our list is the Talon Capture Ionic Smokeless Ashtray. It is an excellent solution for anyone who typically smokes in the same spot time after time – such as at their desk or on the couch next to a small table.
Perhaps the most significant benefit of the Talon Capture Ionic is that you don’t need to worry about batteries – a big hassle with some of the other battery-powered ashtrays on the list. This smokeless ashtray is, however, dual-functioning, so if you choose to unplug and bring your Talon with you, it can operate on battery power.
The Talon Capture Ionic Smokeless Ashtray is also our list’s only ionic smoke eater. That means that the unit uses a negative ion engine to eliminate airborne contaminants from the environment by hitting them with a quick electrical charge.
Perfect Life Ideas Smokeless Ashtray
Great Low-Cost Smoke Solution
Taking up the number eight and final spot on our list is the Perfect Life Ideas Smokeless Ashtray. While lacking the fan power, quietness, and longevity of most smokeless ashtrays on our list, the Perfect Life Ideas is a common choice for an outdoor or temporary-use smokeless ashtray.
Don’t expect it to work perfectly in eliminating smoke from your home. You’ll likely be pleased with the Perfect Life Ideas Smokeless Ashtray – especially if you’re looking for a short-term solution to minimizing the smoke released into the air.
Smokeless Ashtray Alternatives
At the end of the day, smokeless ashtrays are great for reducing and minimizing the smoke you’re releasing into your home, but none of them will do the job 100%. Many smokers are turning to personal air purifiers as smokeless ashtray alternatives for a more effective and permanent solution.
While these smokeless ashtray alternatives may cost slightly more upfront, they provide far better protection from harmful smoke gases and odors. They are designed to last way longer than even the best smokeless ashtray.
GermGuardian AC4100 3-in-1 Air Cleaning System
Without a doubt, the single best smokeless ashtray alternative on our list is the GermGuardian AC4100 3-in-1 Air Cleaning System. In addition to the charcoal filter found in most smoke eater ashtrays, the GermGuardian AC4100 also utilizes a medical-grade HEPA filter to remove up to 99.97% of all contaminants in your home’s air – including pesky and harmful smoke gases and odors.
Although some buyers in the market for a smokeless ashtray may be a little scared off by the Guardian’s price, it’s essential to keep it in perspective: smokeless ashtrays aren’t meant to last forever, but with proper care and maintenance, the GermGuardian AC4100 is designed to last for years or even decades. Although it requires a slightly higher initial investment, the AC4100 is the best pick for both value and performance over the long term.
Hamilton Beach TrueAir Room Odor Eliminator
Another great desktop personal air purifier is the Hamilton Beach TrueAir Room Odor Eliminator. Designed for single-room use, the Hamilton Beach TrueAir is a smart choice if most of your time smoking is spent in a single room.
Comprised of three separate carbon filters, the TrueAir from Hamilton Beach is rated to keep a 100-square-foot space clean and fresh for three months. It also uses less energy than the average 15-watt lightbulb, meaning that all you have to do is replace the filters every few months and enjoy the clean, fresh air.
Holmes HEPA-Type Desktop Air Purifier
If the size is an issue and you’re looking for the smallest desktop air filter possible, look closer at the Holmes HEPA-Type Desktop Air Purifier. The Holmes is a solid, value-priced alternative to the GermGuardian and Hamilton Beach models, an excellent smokeless ashtray alternative for buyers seeking an effective and long-term solution.
Rated with a CADR of 70 and recommended for spaces up to 109 square feet in size, the Holmes HEPA-Type Desktop Air Purifier can take in, filter, and send back out seventy cubic feet of air every minute. The unit is also equipped with three different fan speed settings giving you the flexibility to customize its performance to your own unique smoke-eating needs.
GermGuardian GG1000 Pluggable UV-C Air Sanitizer
Do you want a long-term smokeless ashtray alternative but don’t have the desk or counter space for one of the other desktop models on our list? You’ll probably be interested in the GermGuardian GG1000 Pluggable UV-C Air Sanitizer.
The only plug-style smoke eater on our list, the GermGuardian GG1000 is the perfect out-of-the-way answer for the buyer with limited space. It’s also popular among buyers who don’t want a noticeable air purifier sitting out in the open at eye level.
Unlike the other charcoal-filtered and HEPA-filtered smokeless ashtray alternatives, the GermGuardian GG100 uses UV-C technology to eliminate harmful particles and odors with UV-C light.
Why Use a Smokeless Ashtray
You’d be surprised to find out how many people ask why use a smokeless ashtray in the first place. It should seem pretty straightforward: using a smokeless ashtray can significantly reduce the smoke released from your resting cigarette or cigar.
Not only can smoke smell be complicated to get out of your furniture and carpet, and many of the chemicals in smoke will stain your ceilings and walls, but it’s also highly hazardous to spend the majority of your time in a closed-in space full of the airborne contaminants found in tobacco smoke.
Although smokeless ashtrays alone won’t entirely prevent smoke from contaminating your home, they are a significant first step in reducing long-lasting odors and other potentially harmful gases.
Do Smokeless Ashtrays Actually Work?
Many buyers are often skeptical of how well smokeless ashtrays work. For a good reason: top air purifiers can cost hundreds of dollars. It should be evident that a value-priced smokeless ashtray will provide less smoke-eating and protection than a high-end air purifier would. Still, in their own regard, a smokeless ashtray does help reduce smoke.
Most smokeless ashtrays operate by having an internal fan that sucks air in through the top, where you would place the lit end of your cigarette or cigar. As the fan spins and brings the smoke into the unit, an internal carbon filter (or two, as in the case of some of the models on our top 8 list) then works to absorb the odor and chemicals contaminating the air. This leads to clean air being released back into your room.
However, smokeless ashtrays only work when the cigarette is resting in them. The smokeless ashtray won’t be very helpful if you habitually hold your cigarette in your hand between puffs. Likewise, smokeless ashtray fans and filtration power aren’t powerful enough to remove the smoke you exhale.
How Do You Use a Smokeless Ashtray?
Using a smokeless ashtray is a pretty straightforward process. It’s important to understand that each unit will operate differently. Pay attention and understand how a specific model works before purchasing it.
Most smokeless ashtrays on the market operate by having a small fan draw the smoke in and pass it through a filter. Most filters are comprised of carbon. The carbon binds with the chemicals in the smoke and traps them in the filter.
You typically use a smokeless ashtray just like an ordinary ashtray. Almost all have a tray for resting your cigarette or cigar, with the fan and filter underneath. Some even have a cover on top to keep smoke in and minimize the amount released into the room.
Best Cigarette Ashtray: Smokeless
There’s no question about it: if you smoke cigarettes and are looking for a smokeless ashtray for your home, the number one pick should be the Holmes Smoke Grabber. Because of its unique design and enhanced functionality, the Smoke Grabber is powerful enough to absorb even the most pungent cigarette odors.
Best Cigar Ashtray: Smokeless
While we here at Respectable Reviews believe that the Holmes Smoke Grabber is also an excellent choice for cigar smokers, we may have to give this title to the Talon Capture Ionic Smokeless Ashtray.
That’s because cigar smokers typically do so in the same spot time after time, unlike cigarette smokers, who often prefer to be more mobile. As such, a powerful desktop plug-in smoke eater like the Talon Capture Ionic can leverage its enhanced performance while mitigating the downside of its solid and stationary design.
Best Smokeless Ashtray 2023?
Here, in one convenient and easy-to-read spot, are our top picks for best smokeless ashtray of 2023:
- Holmes Smoke Grabber
- Gratefulbuys Smokeless Ashtray
- Kingstar Smokeless Ashtray
- Rerii Automotive Smokeless Ashtray
- Smart TV Solutions Smokeless Ashtray
- Zone Tech Car Smokeless Ashtray
- Talon Capture Ionic Smokeless Ashtray
- Perfect Life Ideas Smokeless Ashtray
And then there were our effective and long-lasting smokeless ashtray alternatives: